Gwyneth Paltrow Wore Penny Loafers, Score Similar Styles from $38

A penny for our thoughts? Gwyneth Paltrow’s loafers are so “in” for fall. 

On September 27, the Goop founder got all dressed up for her birthday festivities in Portofino, Italy. She looked ready to celebrate in a classy pussy-bow blouse (which Kate Middleton also just wore), a sumptuous zip-up sweater, and some cropped wide-leg pants. 

And because a pair of heels would be totally impractical for the cobblestone streets, she completed the look with some preppy penny loafers — which are a “true classic making a comeback,” according to stylist Cynthia Kennedy. Plus, they “instantly make jeans or trousers look more polished without sacrificing comfort,” she previously told PEOPLE. 

Penny Loafers Inspired by Gwyneth Paltrow

Coutgo Penny Loafers

These Coutgo loafers are an absolute “must.” Not only are they really comfortable — one shopper wears them for 12-hour days — but they also look nicer than your average sneakers. The heel collapses down, so you can wear them as mules on warmer fall days. So really, you’re getting two styles for the price of one. 

G.H. Bass Weejuns Penny Loafer

I don’t have penny loafers from G.H. Bass, but I do have loafers from the brand. They feel (and smell) like other luxury pairs that I have, and they’re much sturdier than my light-as-air ballet flats. So as soon as the heat dies down in Arizona, I will break them out for good this season to wear with everything from capris à la Paltrow to maxi skirts to jeans.    

Eastland Classic II Leather Loafer

If you’re clumsy like me, you might want a pair with a little more traction for rainy or snowy days. (Look at Paltrow, you never know when it might start pouring!) If so, this discounted pair is your best bet since it has a “grip sole” for more stability. Speaking of stability, it also has a 1-inch heel for a little bit of a lift that won’t have you toppling over with each step. 

Keep scrolling to shop more penny loafers inspired by Gwyneth Paltrow. 

A New Day Phyllis Penny Loafers with Memory Foam Insole

Beauseen Penny Loafers

Qjn Penny Loafers

Dr. Scholl’s Hello Loafer

Cole Haan Stassi Penny Loafer