Podiatrist-Approved Supportive Fall Shoes Start at $55 on Amazon

Throughout my 20s and early 30s, I didn’t own flats. I lived in New York City, and could be seen standing for hours on end at events or running all over town, Carrie Bradshaw style, feet clad in sky-high stilettos. But when I suffered a painful ankle break in my mid-30s, I had to change my ways — which meant foregoing heels in favor of shoes that are both cute and comfortable.

That’s why I tapped two podiatrists, Dr. Adenike Sonaike and Dr. Elizabeth Bass Daughtry, for their recommendations on the most stylish yet supportive fall shoes. Ahead, find their must-have ankle boots, loafers, clogs, and slip-on sneakers, from brands including Clarks, Revitalign, Dr. Scholl’s, Vionic, and Brooks. They’re all available on Amazon, starting at $55.

Podiatrist-Approved Fall Shoes on Amazon

Dr. Scholl’s Madison Cloud Slip-On Sneakers

Give your sneakers collection a stylish upgrade with these faux suede slip-ons, which are similar to a pair Martha Stewart wore recently. Dr. Sonaike says they provide “comfort and support,” and help relieve “pressure relief on the heels and balls of the feet.” They’re finished with elastic side panels, and they come in sizes 4–13, with regular, wide, and extra-wide widths available.

Revitalign Lambert Ankle Boots

Noting features like a metatarsal dome, deep heel cup, and anatomically designed arch support, Dr. Daughtry says these ankle boots “offer doctor-designed, superior orthotic support.” Plus, they have a “premium look and feel,” and the “easy slip on and off” style helps them be “flexible but secure,” she adds. The booties feature tonal stitched detailing around the front and sides, stacked heels, and side-zip closures.

Clarks Westlynn Bella Loafers

Loafers are majorly trending for fall, with celebs like Gwyneth Paltrow, Kirsten Dunst, and Kate Middleton all incorporating them into their recent outfits. Try the trend with this Dr. Sonaike-recommended pair, which have a “firm heel counter to prevent pronation and good outsole traction.” They have sturdy lug soles, wide tongues with scalloped trim, and tassel details. The loafers come in 11 colors and your choice of smooth leather or suede, plus sizes 5–12.

Vionic Klara Skimmer Ballet Flats

If you’ve been wanting to wear ballet flats à la Zoë Kravitz, Jennifer Lawrence, and Katie Holmes, Dr. Daughtry likes this pair. She specifically points to the contoured arch support for “excellent shock-absorbing cushioning,” adding, “Not many women’s flats offer adequate arch support, and these flats have removable insoles that help correct pronation and promote full-body alignment.” Plus, they come in over 25 colors and sizes 5–13.

Brooks Ghost 2 Max Sneakers

Chunky white sneakers will always be in style — just look at Lindsay Lohan, who wore them on a recent travel day. Dr. Sonaike recommends these Brooks sneakers for “regular runners and walkers” thanks to “extra cushion,” noting they’ll last “through the fall running season and beyond.” 

Dansko Berry Mules

Clogs have made a serious style comeback in recent months, and these mules with stacked heels are equal parts retro-inspired, fashionable, and supportive. Dr. Daughtry likes the shoes’ memory foam insoles, which offer “excellent shock absorption, cushioning, and adequate support.” Choose from a variety of neutral hues, including navy, black, chocolate brown, and gray, plus sizes 5–12.