Shailene Woodley Supports Thomas Doherty at Little Shop of Horrors

Shailene Woodley stopped by Skid Row on Tuesday, Sept. 16, to support Thomas Doherty on his opening night of Little Shop of Horrors Off-Broadway.

The Big Little Lies actress, 33 — who will be seen in season 2 of Hulu’s Paradise opposite Doherty — dressed in all black for the evening out, adding a pop of color to her ensemble with a bright red coat.

She posed for a photo after the performance with a Little Shop of Horrors “Feed Me” baseball cap handed out to guests.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Doherty, 30, is playing meek flower shop assistant Seymour in the treasured musical, about a strange and unusual plant that feeds only on human flesh and blood. He stars opposite Emmy nominee Madeline Brewer (The Handmaid’s Tale, Orange Is the New Black) who plays Audrey, Seymour’s coworker and crush who dreams of finding happiness somewhere that’s green.

Directed by Tony Award winner Michael Mayer (Hedwig and the Angry Inch, Spring Awakening), Little Shop of Horrors opened to widespread critical acclaim in October 2019. The treasured musical features a book and lyrics by Howard Ashman and music by Alan Menken, and features some of the most beloved songs in musical theater history including “Somewhere That’s Green” and the show-stopping duet “Suddenly, Seymour.”

Both Brewer and Doherty are making their New York stage debuts in the revival, now in its sixth smash year at the Westside Theatre in New York City.

Currently joining them in the cast are Drama Desk nominee Jeremy Kushnier (Footloose, Jesus Christ Superstar) as Dr. Orin Scrivello DDS, Tony Award nominee Reg Rogers (The Dazzle, Merrily We Roll Along) as Mushnik, Major Attaway as The Voice of Audrey II, Christine Wanda as Ronnette, Savannah Lee Birdsong as Crystal, and Morgan Ashley Bryant as Chiffon, as well as Teddy Yudain, Jonothon Lyons, Mecca Hicks, Aveena Sawyer, Jeff Sears, Noel MacNeal, Johnny Newcomb, Jon Riddleberger, David Colston Corris, Bryan Fenkart, Alloria Frayser, Christopher Swan and Chani Maisonet.

Other stars in the audience for Tuesday’s opening night included RuPaul’s Drag Race winner Trixie Mattel, social media star Brittany Broski, 99 to Beat star Tommy Bracco and actor Nicole Brydon Bloom, who stars alongside Woodley and Doherty in season 2 of Paradise.

Evan Mock, Doherty’s costar from Gossip Girl, was also in the crowd, as was Elizabeth Lail — who worked with Brewer in You.

Conrad Ricamora was there, too. He previously played Seymour in the Off-Broadway production.

After the show, the stars headed to an afterparty at Sir Henry’s in New York City, where they dined on appetizers and celebrated with drinks.

Woodley skipped the bash.

A day earlier, on Monday, Sept. 15, sources told PEOPLE that she and boyfriend Lucas Bravo had split. The former couple, who debuted their romance when they first stepped out together in Paris on March 23, even deleted photos of each other from their respective Instagram pages.

Tickets to Little Shop of Horrors are on sale now.