Skeptical Andy Cohen Grills Kyle Stillie About His Alleged Sexual Interaction With A Married Charter Guest: “I’m Getting A Few Different Stories”

Below Deck star Kyle Stillie knows how to rock the boat.

During Below Deck Season 12, Episode 11, Stillie drunkenly claimed that he had sex with topless charter guest Helen while she was using him as a floatation device mere feet away from her husband in Episode 10. When word got back to Captain Kerry Titheradge, Stillie—now in a position to lose his job on the yacht—immediately backtracked his claim that he “slipped it in” during their sensual swim.

Following the episode, Stillie and chief stew Fraser Olender appeared on Watch What Happens Live, where host Andy Cohen tried his best to get to the bottom of what actually happened that fateful day in the ocean.

When asked if he had any sexual interaction with Helen, Stillie said, “No. Definitely didn’t. No.”

However, he added, “There was a point in time when I was in that sea, where I thought potentially something may have happened. But nothing happened … I was trying to be professional, and she was very much moving my hands towards her chest. There was a point in time where I will admit, I was slightly aroused.”

Cohen pressed further, asking why he would say he had sex with Helen in both his conversations with the crew and his interview with producers at the end of the episode.

“It’s not my most proud moment. I don’t know why I said it, Andy. I’m not necessarily proud of what I did. I really can’t give you an answer on why I said it,” Stillie said, noting that he “hopes not to hear” from Helen and her husband now that the episode has aired.

Cohen, meanwhile, was skeptical of Stillie. When Olender claimed his crew-mate was being “a bit wishy-washy,” Cohen agreed, “I’m getting a few different stories.”

“It’s also an odd thing for you to be in the water and think, ‘Oh, I think maybe it went in,’” Cohen added. “I do feel like that’s something that you would definitively know.”

Watch What Happens Live airs Sunday through Thursday at 10 p.m. ET on Bravo. New episodes are available to stream the next day on Peacock.