Woman Keeps Sister’s Elopement Secret, Family Calls Out Her Betrayal

A woman seeks advice from the Reddit community following an emotional fallout with her family after keeping her sister’s secret. In her post, the 27-year-old shares that she recently found herself “caught in the middle of some family drama,” and she isn’t sure if she handled it the right way.

She explains that her oldest sister, 33, married young at 19 to a man who was 25. “They were together for about 10 years, had 2 kids, and then had a very messy and very public divorce,” the woman recalls.

After the divorce, her sister started dating someone much younger. “She got with a younger guy (21M at the time), things blew up with the family, and she basically cut contact with all of us,” the poster says. For years, her sister stopped attending family gatherings, keeping her distance from the rest of them.

In recent years, the oldest sister found love again and built a blended family. “She’s now with someone new, they’ve been engaged, and she’s raising 3 kids plus his older child,” the woman explains. Though the relationship has been serious, family tensions have kept her sister from coming around.

Originally, the couple had been planning a wedding for May. But after learning she was pregnant, the sister and her fiancé decided to elope at the courthouse instead. This major decision would end up at the center of the family conflict.

The poster reveals that she and her sister had not been speaking until recently. “I’ve been struggling with a move and a miserable new job, and when I confided in my mother, she just tore me down and made me feel worse,” she writes, admitting that painful moment made her reflect on the complicated family dynamics she grew up with.

After that conversation, she began to understand her sister’s distance. “It clicked why my sister had distanced herself all these years,” she admits. Comparing her mother’s harshness to the kindness she experienced from her boyfriend’s mom, she realized the weight of their upbringing.

She describes her mother’s parenting style as one that left lasting scars. “My mom always told us growing up, she would give us her opinion whether we like it or not, she will always be truthful,” she says. But she adds that her mother has “a [habit] of just making us feel awful instead of supported in anything her opinion doesn’t align with.”

This realization pushed her to reconnect with her sister. “I called my sister, we reconnected, and I confided in her about my resignation,” the poster shares. In turn, her sister trusted her with the secret of her elopement and pregnancy, asking her not to tell anyone.

The woman agreed, keeping the information close. But when the news eventually came out, the rest of the family was shocked. “Today the news broke to the family. I didn’t lie when they asked me, I admitted that my sister FaceTimed me this morning and told me, but I said it wasn’t my place to share,” she says.

She made a conscious choice not to mention the pregnancy. “Again, not my story to tell,” she explains. However, that decision only stirred more frustration among her mother and middle sister, who both felt left in the dark.

“My middle sister and my mom were mad that I kept it from them. Things ended awkwardly,” the poster recalls. Later, her middle sister reached out to her directly, revealing just how hurt their mother felt.

According to her, their mother said, “Well I guess I’m just the villain,” upset that both daughters were keeping their distance and holding back secrets. “My middle sister said she was very upset and sounded like she was gonna cry,” the poster admits.

Now the woman is questioning whether she did the right thing by protecting her sister’s privacy. “On one hand, I feel like I honored my sister’s trust and did the right thing,” she says. But she also admits, “On the other, my mom and middle sister clearly feel betrayed, and now there’s more tension in the family.”

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Reddit commenters offered their perspective, with many praising her decision to respect her sister’s wishes. One user tells her, “You knew this wasn’t your story to tell, and you rightly believed that your sister should be the one to share her own life events, on her own terms.”

Another commenter reassures her that privacy matters more than curiosity. “You honored your sister’s trust — that’s the right call,” they write. “Family curiosity doesn’t trump someone else’s privacy, especially with sensitive stuff like pregnancy and elopement.”

While her mother and middle sister may feel hurt, the consensus among readers is clear. As one commenter notes, “Your mom and middle sister can be upset all they want, but that doesn’t make you wrong.”

In the end, the poster may not have smoothed over family tensions, but she did protect her sister’s confidence. And for many, that was the right choice to make.