‘Below Deck’ Exclusive Clip: Bárbara Kulaif Feels “Guilty” For Kissing Jess Theron While The Lead Deckhand Was Also Hooking Up With Solené Favreau

Last week’s episode of Below Deck was one for the books: a crew love pentagon, a disastrous departing from port, and an unruly guest who forced Captain Kerry Titheradge to call in the maritime police! There’s truly never a dull moment aboard the motor yacht St. David. This week’s episode finds the yachties picking up the pieces as they continue with their charter. After the expulsion of Helen—the drunken guest who was a danger to herself and others—her compatriots were allowed to continue their trip, basking in the 5-star service provided by Chief Stew Fraser Oleander and enjoying water activities under the guidance of Bosun Hugo Ortega.

This exclusive clip from tonight’s episode picks up as the guests are enjoying a cowboy-themed evening. The crew, dressed in their Western best, entertain the party as Chef Anthony Iracane serves a delectable seafood bouillabaisse. However, downstairs in the guest cabin is where the real drama is happening. Though both are vying for Lead Deckhand Jess Theron’s heart, Stews Bárbara Kulaif and Solené Favreau are seen working together to desperately try to remove mysterious lipstick stains from a couch in a guest cabin.

“Maybe she have sex?” wonders Favreau out loud as she makes a gagging noise. After the two deal with the guest mess, they sit down to deal with their own mess. “Is everything okay between us?” asks Kulaif tentatively. After a pause, Favreau nods and says “yeah.” Kulaif breathes a sigh of relief and continues: “I really felt that you’d be upset about Jess.” Favreau, who is clearly used to getting her way with love and hookups, shares her feelings.

“I really liked her, of course,” begins Favreau. “Just today, Jess told me, ‘I like Barbara,’ and I was feeling very bad about that.” Kulaif interrupts Favreau. “We kissed, like, one second at the Carnevale and the first thing that came to my mind was you.” As Favreau listens intently, Kulaif continues. “I was feeling so bad. I was feeling the ‘lover,’ do you know what I mean?”

In her confessional, Kulaif keeps talking. “I am feeling guilty because of this,” says Kulaif to the cameras. “I’m not really happy because I literally lose my friend and Jess is like, you know…” The footage cuts back to Kulaif and Favreau cleaning the guest cabin as Kulaif’s voiceover continues: “And Jess, I don’t think she put me in a nice situation. I don’t think it’s fair.” The clip ends on Kulaif in her interview as she wipes away her tears. “I’m just feeling everything is my fault,” Kulaif says in despair.

Who will Theron choose? Tune in to tonight’s episode of Below Deck at 8/7c on Bravo to find out!